img

Opinion Piece: Do the Russian Want War? The Need for Calm and Historic Reflection to De-Escalate East-West Relations


By Nicholas Cobb, Chairman, Westminster Russia Forum

It is not without a hint of sadness that I write this piece, not for the fact that we are living through a period of severe tensions between Moscow and its Western partners but more for the fact that penning a piece like this has become an annual tradition.

Whilst we are uncertainly living through a period of major and undeniable geopolitical tension between Russia and the West, there is I believe cause for both optimism, in the sense that we will inevitably find our way out of this quagmire as we have always done but also sheer frustration at the lack of partiality in the narrative.

The Danger of Miscalculation

The danger here is of an accidental escalation and this can happen as a result of an operational miscalculation on both sides. Should this happen this will not be the fault of the military but of our politicians and media who seem hell bent on creating a narrative of mistrust, isolation and fear mongering.

Our relations on a population to population level remain strong – we continue to trade and engage culture, albeit at a reduced pre-2014 level but have nonetheless a large Russian diaspora living and working in the UK as well as significant areas for improvement in economic ties.

The problem, as always is politics and the ever-increasing media hype. Our militaries both in the UK / NATO and the Russian Federation are influenced by the media narrative and policy direction of their political masters. As such we are now in a precarious situation where a miscalculation between a naval, air or land engagement on the Ukrainian borderlands or in the Black or Baltic seas could see an accidental escalation that would end with no winners.

We will all lose from such an event.

Defining the Lines in the Sand

It doesn’t matter how we have gotten to this position but the need for de-escalation is now paramount. In the past week or so we have seen not only a welcome return from conjecture to diplomacy – President Putin and his Western counterparts have met and from all accounts the discussions have been tough but business like. So long as strategic dialogue is ongoing we have much cause for optimism and people to people interactions in societal-family, trade and cultural engagements will continue as normal.

It seems that no matter how entrenched or valid the lines in the sand between Moscow and NATO are, there is a lack of communications or understanding of one another’s viewpoints. For Moscow, NATO has broken a number of promises on Eastern expansion and hypocritically blames Russia for aggression whilst it holds military exercises on its border.

For NATO, Russia remains a prickly and difficult adversary and one which cannot for the life of it accept the democratic will of the states of Eastern and Central Europe to plough their own furrow away from its grasp.

Far be it from me to comment of the validity of either of these points but it is worth bearing in mind that what we really lack here is not political will but a complete lack of understanding of one another’s geopolitical position and reading the headlines in the past few weeks one would be forgiven for thinking that this is a wholly new position that we find ourselves in. In short relations were strained well before the crisis in Ukraine and loss of Crimea in 2014 but have continued to sour but we have always found a compromise and diplomatic fudge to avert disaster.

Do the Russians Want War?

Written in 1961 by Yevgeny Yevtushenko, the song ‘Do the Russians want war’ is a poignant piece that evokes not only the peace of the Russian countryside but also a meeting of US and Soviet troops on the Elbe in 1945. This anti-war song is now over 60 years old but sums up the feelings mistrust of the early cold war and is as apt now as it was in 1961. The Russian people didn’t want war then and neither do they now – we inhabit a different world to the cold war, but the similarities are striking and one could be mistaken for thinking that some would welcome its icy embrace.

Reviewing the press these past weeks it seems that there are those that are actively hankering for a conflict but it won’t be the sons and daughters of our esteemed politicians and media elite that fight these wars but those of the UK’s inner cities. No one wins in this escalation, but it makes for an interesting distraction and an easy target.

To move ahead, de-escalate and begin to find a common ground we need to pay less attention to the armchair pundits and cold war warriors and just focus on what we can do, not what we cannot – whilst the media will hype and politicians will deflect blame to a foreign enemy, the vast majority of our people just want to get on and pay little attention to such frivolities with the truth.

Russian has over 150,000 troops within its borders and Ukraine has nearly 100,000 on its side – to invade, Russia would need a much larger ratio of troops and would gain nothing from an incursion aside economic hardship and international isolation. The situation is incredibly serious but there have been multiple examples in the past where lines are pushed to gain a political edge.

The UK has a unique role to play in the world and could do much good in the current crisis – with the prospect of a post brexit trade deal and as an honest broker it could take an active role in promoting peace in the region alongside the United States.

What is needed are cool heads and a reduction in media and pundit hype – this way we empower our professional diplomats and military to plan for a de-escalation within a new framework to accommodate Moscow and its Western partners.

All views expressed are that of the author.


Читайте также:

Мы - лауреаты конкурса "СМИ против коррупции"
Veterans News - победитель конкурса "Щит и перо" 
WVF отметила команду "Ветеранских вестей"

Фото // vvesti.com ©